Thursday, January 5, 2017

Passai Kata


One of the many bunkai from Passai Dai kata - Adam (right) follows up with double high block to stop Ryan (left) from
grabbing his throat and finishes Ryan with double back fist strike. This is just one of many bunkai possibilities for this
part of the kata practiced by members of Seiyo Kai Shorin-Ryu Karate and Kobudo.
Members of the Arizona Hombu dojo located in Mesa, Arizona, learn a kata known as Passai. In this system of Shorin-Ryu Karate known as Seiyo-Kai, members actually learn two different Passai kata: Passai Dai (大 dai meaning major) and Passai Sho (小 sho meaning minor). Passai is nearly universal in traditional karatedo schools, but the kata have many differences depending on the style of karate. Soke Hausel kept these kata relatively intact based on the forms taught to him nearly 50 years ago.

The kata includes a variety of bunkai depending on the ryu. Some historians suggest the kata was created by a left-hand martial artist; while others suggest it was designed to defend against an antagonist armed with bo. Soke Hausel noted that he sees no evidence the kata was created by a left-handed martial artist particularly when there are at least a half-dozen movements that favor right-handed martial artists. As far as defending against bo? Soke Hausel claims there is no evidence for this, other than in Passai sho. And anyone attempting to block a full-force strike of a bo with closed fist blocks like those in Passai dai would spend a lot of time in the ER. Bunkai demos of Japanese Shotokan practitioners emphasize blocking bo using such blocks, but Soke doesn't believe anyone in their right mind would try this with a closed fist block against a bo swung with power. This is because the force of the strike of a bo in flight, would be greatly increased by blocking with an arm producing an additive force of a head-on-collision between the bo and the arm. Visualize blocking a baseball bat swung at full force with your arm - your baseball career would be over. For those unfamiliar with Shotokan - Shotokan is variety of Shorin-Ryu karate introduced to mainland Japan by Funakoshi in 1922.  

As with many kata, the origin of Passai are obscure probably because karate was kept secret for hundreds of years with nothing written about the fighting art until it was introduced to Japan during the second decade in the 20th century. So, we are left to speculation as to where this kata came from, its meaning, and who was the author or authors.

The version of Passai we practice in Seiyo Shorin-Ryu is similar to the form taught by the Okinawan Shorin-Ryu karate masters Anko Itosu and Gichin Funakoshi. It is suggested the Okinawan kata is at least 400 years old based on a silk drawing of the kata that was analyzed using carbon isotope age dating. It is also suggested by others that the kata was originally a form named after a family on Okinawa.

But others turn to the translation of Passai to help find the origin for the kata. The kata is called Passai on Okinawa. On mainland Japan, it is called Bassai. The kata is also found in Korean martial arts such as Taekwondo and Tang Soo Do. In Korea, the kata is known as Bassahee, Bal Se, Pal Che, Palsek, Bal Sae, Ba Sa Hee, and Bal Sak

In Gichin Funakoshi’s 1922 book, the kata is referred to as Passai which was also the name used by Motobu Chōki of Okinawa in 1926. But for some reason, Funakoshi decided to rename the kata as Bassai in 1936. It is suggested Bassai was the Chinese pronunciation.

Karate ka practice Passai sho kata at the Arizona Hombu dojo. This
technique can be interpreted as a defensive posture for taking bo from
another's hand - it can also be used to grab and take a rifle from another
individual. 
The meaning of Passai can be “to penetrate a fortress” or to “extract from a fortress”. The Japanese meaning of batsu is "to pull out or extract” while the Chinese meaning is "to seize or capture”. Additional insight comes from an interpretation of kanji for sai/soku which can mean “fort”. In the 1973 translation of Funakoshi’s book Karate-do Kyohan, the author refers to the kata as “Breaking through an enemy's fortress.”

This may be in reference to the power in which the kata (especially closed-fist blocks) is executed, as well as emphasizing power from hip rotation. The kata focuses on destroying an attacker’s defense with very strong and powerful blocks. When we practice this kata, we have a feeling of precise movements with fast execution of each individual technique, with attention to balance, speed and power. Remember the TV series ‘Tool Time’ - this is a kata that needs MORE POWER to be done properly! Each closed-fist block in the first half of the Passai dai kata needs every ounce of power, strength and speed you can muster. Your blocks should shake the walls of the dojo! If you practice this kata like tai chi (slow and with no power) you are doing yourself a great disservice and butchering the art. You need to feel the power and snap in every closed fist block!

Extracting rifle using bunkai from Passai sho kata
So, it may be that the kata was an Okinawan family kata or had some other lineage. Even so, karate has its origins in Chinese gung-fu. After Okinawan martial artists learned gung-fu in China, they stream-lined or remove many of the aesthetic movements and deep stances, and developed a more pragmatic self-defense system. It is thought this kata also originated from Chinese boxing before it fell into the hands of Okinawan martial artists. This is supported by Gichin Funakoshi who stated that the form is “a Shōrin-ryū form derived from Chinese Shaolin styles”. 

Some historians point to similarities of Leopard and Lion gung-fu to movements in the kata. Okinawan karate historian Akio Kinjo believes the name of this kata originated from the Chinese term “bàoshī” meaning “leopard-lion” which is pronounced “bá-săi” or “pà-sai” in some Chinese dialects. Other historians see a resemblance to Wuxing Quan (Five Element Fist) gung fu. 

There are several Okinawan versions of Passai. The version practiced by members of Seiyo no Shorin-Ryu Karate Kobudo Kai could be termed Itosu no Passai Dai or Funakoshi no Passai Dai to imply the version of our kata was authored by these two great Okinawan karate men. Anko Itosu popularized karate by introducing it into the Okinawan school curriculum. Itosu was also known for modifying kata to fit his karate personality. He modified Passai Dai from the Matsumura version. The Passai who kata is thought to have been created by Itosu. Funakoshi, a student of Itosu, also modified the kata when introduced to Japan.

Soke Hausel explains to clinic attendees, the use of bunkai
from Passai kata.
It is also interesting to note that Passai may have roots in Tomari village on Okinawa, simply because Passai dai begins with the right fist covered by the left hand, like other kata thought to have originated from Tamari, such as Jutte, Jion, Giin and Empi. This hand gesture is a common salutation in China. 

Watching some variations of this kata on videos just to see the differences employed by different karate schools. It is important to look at every variation because one can sometimes gain important insight into the bunkai.

No comments:

Post a Comment